Two dogs rescued from Hurricane Florence in school bus shot and killed

In Greenback, Tennessee, two dogs rescued from Hurricane Florence in a school bus were shot and killed last week by a neighbor who stated a fight had broken out with four dogs that had been in a pen together.

The dogs had been part of a rescue operation by Tony Alsup, 51, who drove a school bus to hurricane ravaged areas and picked up pets in need. More than 60 dogs and cats had been rescued, and they were all to be sent to shelters in other states for adoption.

According to WvltNews, Alsup had four dogs rescued from the Saint Frances Animal Center staying at his home for a night. Two of the dogs were shot on October 19 and one other dog was injured. The Blount County Sheriff’s Office report stated two of the dogs were attacking a third dog. Alsup’s wife and young grandchild were home at the time and tried to break up the fight, but were not able – even spraying the one dog with a hose. Animal Control was not able to come over; instead a neighbor came over and shot the dogs stating he saved the third pup.  Devon Smith, the executive director of St. Frances Animal Center in Georgetown, South Carolina had already been suspicious not having heard any news about the dogs’ welfare. She was not told what happened until days later.

Saint Frances Animal Center wrote about the heartbreaking situation on their Facebook page:

“…As we updated you during the hurricane, we evacuated dogs with the help of many rescue groups. This included a transporter that we had not worked with prior to the hurricane. We made calls to verify that other groups had worked with this person, and questioned him about his plan for the dogs. We then followed up post-hurricane, to make sure we knew where our animals were, and that they were safe. It was not enough, and that will haunt us.

This transporter, whom we had not been familiar with previously, was unable to tell us where the dogs were after the storm. Through lots of calls and sleuthing, we were able to find where most of them went ourselves. And we were working to have 8 of those dogs returned to us, as they were delivered to groups who had, as we later found out, not agreed to or been able to take them permanently.”

Four of the dogs, Whiskey, Humphrey, Mandy and Domino had been at the foster home as the rescue had been working on details to get the dogs returned.  That’s when the tragedy occurred.

“On Friday, the foster transported Whiskey, Humphrey, Mandy, and Domino to the original transporter’s property, until they could come back to us. We were not aware of this transfer in advance. When they arrived at the original transporter’s house, Whiskey, Humphrey, and Domino were put in a small pen together, in spite of the foster advising against this plan. These dogs were not housed together at our shelter, or at the foster’s house, so they are not familiar with each other. They were in a strange place, with people they didn’t yet know. They were in a constricted space. Domino had been ill. You can imagine how scary and stressful it was for them. As any of you who are familiar with dogs knows, this is simply not safe or humane dog handling.”

That is when the fight broke out. As the foster and neighbors were not familiar with dog behavior and fighting, Humphrey and Whiskey were shot and killed.

“Video suggests that the dogs were not fighting when they were shot.

Fortunately, the foster who had cared for all four of the dogs for the last month returned to the house and saved Domino, and he is safe in her care. Mandy is still at the house where Whiskey and Humphrey were killed. We are doing our best to have her returned to us immediately, but unfortunately, the original transporter is so far refusing to do so. Her safety is our top priority right now. We have been in contact with the Sheriff’s Dept and Animal Control in the county where this happened.”

The tragic deaths of Humphrey and Whiskey have deeply affected the rescue, and they have pledged to review processes in disaster situations as not to make the same mistake of trusting someone they didn’t know. Domino had bites on his front legs, head and throat and is currently recovering. Mandy is reported to be in a safe location and both dogs are expected to return to the South Carolina on Sunday.

Rest in peace.

(Photos of dogs killed after being rescued from Hurricane Florence via Facebook)

Follow the National Pet Rescue on Facebook for the latest animal news.

Former bait dog overcomes horrible past

Remarkable recovery

5 replies
  1. Animal Advocate says:

    Sad all the way around. I wonder if the transporters intentions were good and he was just ignorant. Not returning phone calls sounds suspicious and common sense with any transport is to keep dogs separated that were that away originally Vetting is important with transporters as is the pets final
    destination to make sure they aren’t going to a hoarding situation or fighting situation.

  2. Jan Barnes says:

    Rest in peace, dear angels!

    Also, to St. Frances Shelter–God would not want you to be haunted by this because you had no way to predict this would happen!

    Please remember all the animals you saved that would not be with us today without you and your unyielding hard work and dedication! God bless you all!

  3. Pierre says:

    Why would this organization trust some random guy with a bus to pick up pit bulls? They should be haunted for not having ANY checks on what happened to the animals after the pick up. These people should be vetted to the teeth but yet again…oops…
    I wonder if they are counting these poor dogs among those they have saved.

    • Pam says:

      From other information given by the organization, they had spoken to others who had used him in the past. Follow up communication with him after he had the dogs was lacking on his end, not answering or returning calls. Agree, with Animal Advocate above.

  4. Dalma Bugg says:

    So very sad there was no better idea than shooting the two dogs, RIP Whiskey and Humphrey, run free OTRB.
    I think the pressure people were under to save lives at all costs during the hurricane possibly led to rash decisions which would normally be better thought out. The urgency of the situation and not wanting to repeat the experience in previous weather events has undoubtedly brought about this current tragedy but I’m sure that lesson no have been learned and we need to remember now t all facts are available yet. It is sad that this bus driver now seems to be, understandably, under a cloud as he was hailed as a hero for his rescue effort. If his intentions were not good at the time, then I pray he meets with the full force f the justice system, which begs the question – under what jurisdiction will this case lie? He is doing himself no favours atm by being cagey regarding the information sought from him.


Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *