Canada judge questions pit bull ban: Lacks clarity

Spread the love

On Monday morning, Superior Court Justice Louis Gouin questioned Quebec’s pit bull bylaw stating he has concerns over how a “pit bull type dog” is defined, reports the CBC. The bylaw came into effect on Monday.

In response to Montreal SPCA asking for a judicial review of the law banning pit bulls, the organization asked the court to suspend the bylaw stating it will prevent “chaos” and confusion during the review process until the outcome is completed.

“I won’t hide from you that in my reading of the bylaw I had several questions,” stated Judge Gouin. “Are we talking about first generation crosses? Do we go back to the grandparents? If I have all these questions, then the owners of pit bull type dogs must have them as well.”

Also being questioned is what the definition of a “pit bull type dog” is and that the new bylaw is both “vague and imprecise.” The new law suggests that these dogs be required to be muzzled at all times – a task impossible stated the judge since the dogs would not be able to eat or drink. Representing the city’s legal department, Rene Cadieux told the judge the dogs should be muzzled at all times when they go outdoors, and that Montreal had planned to update the website specifically citing the new regulations. Also in question is the city workers’ right to enter a building and arbitrarily take someone’s dog.

In Cadieux’s  argument to the judge, he referred to the Supreme Court’s decision stating there is no scientific evidence needed for breed specific legislation, and it is perfectly legal to rely on logic and common sense. Meanwhile lawyers for the SPCA, Marie-Claude St. Amant and Sibel Ataogul are looking for a resolution by Wednesday.

And as if Ontario’s  latest bylaws against dogs isn’t worrisome enough, Premier Philippe Couillard said Quebec is likely to follow the lead and ban pit bulls also.

Citizens continue to question why the government didn’t meet with the SPCA and other humane organizations to arrive at logical resolutions instead of targeting dogs and their owners in such a heated and undeserved hatred campaign. There has never been an documented evidence that pit bulls, pit bull mixes, or their pit bull relatives dating back six generations are unpredictable. In fact, pit bulls are not a breed – they are a combination of several breeds including the American Pit Bull terrier, the American Staffordshire terrier, American bulldog, etc. When will the government wake up and look at the owners of the dogs – not the dogs?

Follow the National Pet Rescue on Facebook.

(Photo: Riverside Animal Shelter. Darla – rescued!)

Spread the love

More from author


  1. These laws are EVIL. What’s even worse in this case, however, is that it’s in response to an attack by a dog known to be ANOTHER breed, thought to be a BOXER, and which has been DNA proven to be a lab mix. The only other dogs in Montreal who’ve killed anyone are HUSKIES! So what, exactly, do pit bulls have to do with dog attacks in Montreal and the need for this law (which really should be aimed at people anyway, since the dog who attacked was a KNOWN PROBLEM DOG!)? NOTHING! The mayor who pushed this is an inhumane idiot who needs to be fired.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related posts

Latest posts

More than 80 dogs rescued in Richland County living in ‘deplorable’ conditions

In Richland County, Ohio, the Humane Society located in Mansfield joined together with volunteers and staff members over the weekend to rescue 82 dogs...

Police facing backlash and public outcry after officer shoots and kills two dogs on Interstate

In Heyburn, Indiana, on Saturday, officers from the Heyburn Police Department had been dispatched to Interstate 84 for two loose dogs running precariously on...

Queens dog groomer charged with animal abuse after death of young Maltese

In Queens, New York a dog groomer was arrested late last week and charged with animal abuse after a four-year-old Maltese died while being...

Want to stay up to date with the latest news?

We would love to hear from you! Please fill in your details and we will stay in touch. It's that simple!